To our friends puzzled by our bellicosity on Pakistan: we neither wish for war, nor -- conversely & crucially -- understand wishful thinking about war.
With Pakistan, we may presently have a war, interrupted -- but it's war all the same, an unprovoked war imposed on us by an unrepentant enemy. Many Indians -- good folks all -- wishfully interpret this present interruption as the war's end, this mere comma as a full stop. Instinctively, they now seek a win-win aftermath to war.
Yes, war is a terrible thing, however its unquenched embers are even worse; this still-smoldering coal is hardly good foundation even for castles in the air.
Let's be crystal clear about one thing: there may be win-win outcomes in love, but never in war. Here, either one prevails or one goes down.
By prevailing, we don't mean destroying cities and traumatizing the enemy's people (in Pakistan's case, its people are as much a victim of their rulers' dark hearts as Indians are); we mean defeating the enemy in his mind: savaging his assumptions, debasing his dreams, charring his resolve, and eliminating his war-waging capacity.
Only then, from this rubble of the enemy's neutered psyche, we can finally begin imagining a win-win future.
Have we learnt nothing from the ugly wars of the century just passed? After the first great European war, Versailles naively left intact defeated Germany's intent and capacity for war. A beaten, but unbroken, Germany then burned Europe to ground in less than 25 years. After the second great European war, Germany was psychologically crushed. Its post-war prosperity was then built on the foundation of Third Reich's rubble.
In 1991, Saddam Hussein was repulsed from Kuwait, but his megalomania and his war-machine wasn't smashed. He then portrayed himself as an Arab victim of American hegemony, and viciously crushed his Shia subjects. In 2003, after his globally-beamed dental exam, that game was finally over.
Let's return to Pakistan. India did not seek partition; it was imposed on us. India did not seek the subsequent wars; every one of them were imposed on us.
The Pakistani assumptions underlying this dark history, as we know well, are quite racist in nature. Most Pakistani kids are brought up on the tripe that Indians are lesser than them, a weak -- and immoral -- people, unfairly ruling a large geography that should be fragmented.
Pakistan dreams of being an equal to India in geo-political clout; some there even dream of hoisting their flag on Delhi's Red Fort.
In a supposedly conciliatory speech after December 13th, 2001, Pervez Musharraf spoke about Kashmir running in his blood. He was alluding there to his nation's -- his army's, his people's -- jihadist resolve to, one day, pry away the Himalayan territory from an inherently "weak" India. He's also repeatedly articulated his reasons for Pakistan's so-called "U-Turns" on terrorism and war: these are tactical adjustments given 9/11. Why should we assume this as a permanent change of heart?
As for Pakistan's war-making capacity, it has an economy sufficiently large to support, if necessary, a conventional war that can damage India greatly. It also has the bomb.
So, when our bellicose enemy stands proud with his racist assumptions, his covetous dreams, his jihadist resolve, and his war-machinery intact, how is it that thoughtful Indians think the war is over? Are we really sure we want to open up our greatest asset -- the ambition and enterprise of our free and heterogeneous people -- to an enemy whose uncreating and bigoted hand will burn it all down?
We pose these questions to our friends, and finally this: how can trading trinkets with evil possibly vanquish the darkness in its heart?
- ► 2011 (14)
- ► 2006 (194)
- Bribery Allegations Against MPs
- Deep Throat's Identity Revealed
- On Temperance In Language
- HIV in India
- Democracy in Asia
- War, Interrupted
- Paris Hilton: A Sign Of Human Progress!!!
- Friday Musings
- Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc
- The Great Wall of India
- HIV in India
- On Death
- King Fahd
- Ismail Merchant Is No More
- IIT Update
- Sunil Dutt
- The Jewel In The Cobra's Mouth
- The Hague vs. Camp Cropper
- One Year of Manmohan Singh
- The Anti-Secular Reservations At AMU
- On Punditry
- Battling the Ocean
- Tiananmen Square, Redux?
- Blog on Vacation
- iPOD is Dead
- An Isolationist Re-interpretation of WWII
- UN: Out Of Our 'Hood!
- Cool News From Pakistan
- Remedial Physics Lesson Needed
- The Den Of Spies
- India Dimming?
- Pigs At The Trough
- Why Blogs Matter
- Good News From Afghanistan
- Indians Seeking Saudi Citizenship?
- The Sissification Of IITs
- General Aurora R.I.P.
- Pogrom Poems
- Don't Throw Stones If You're In A Glass House
- Arjun He Ain't!
- No Kidding!
- The Interpreter
- ▼ May (45)